The Hag and the Brute

There are two figures that are particularly important in terms of close relationships. They are not so much linked to particular astrology charts or even personality types but rather seem to be universal. In a sense they represent images of two archetypal extremes. One is masculine, the other feminine and they inhabit their own relative positions and express themselves in peculiarly negative masculine and feminine ways. Which one comes first it is impossible to say but each seems to awaken the other.

The Hag

The feminine pole of this pair appears as the figure of the hag. The theme of the hag is common in folklore. One of the more well known stories in which a hag appears is the story of Lady Ragnell who has been transformed into the most loathsome hag as punishment for being wilful and daring to want sovereignty and dominion over her life. In this story she must stay thus until the most handsome and noble knight in the land (Gawain) should, of his own volition, both wed her and grant her the power to exercise her own free will.

Originally hags were boundary figures inhabiting the space between the village and wilds beyond, later it came to mean witch or evil spirit in female form (aren’t they always). Any man who kissed a hag it was believed would have their life blood sucked out of them, it is this that fed into the witch trials, where accused women, often widowed, poor, or otherwise outside the protection of family structures, were cast as hags ~ repulsive, malevolent, sexually spent, dangerous and without value.

In the case of Lady Ragnell her hideous appearance is punishment for daring to request self-determination, and the kiss (or the gift of personal dominion) is what breaks her curse and restores her beauty. Hag figures are powerful expressions of the same underlying anxiety and fear of feminine power paying out on some or other terrible outrage and the need to avenge this primal violation.

How then does she manage to appear so uncomfortably often in relationships? It is not as though she is invited. Rather, she simply appears, is there and takes over and becomes her, indeed she may not even be aware of it at the time. The outrage and rancour are there though and men recoil and react to it, not surprising really since it is usually targeted at them. The tone of voice, the sense of injury, rage and impotence, overt and covert, that underpins her otherwise domestic complaints, eating away, poisoning interactions.

One of the things women seek in their men is relationship, and the need to be seen, heard and valued within that relationship. Recognised, appreciated and related with for who they are. If this is lacking it can be seen as the husband’s fault. In time what rises from beneath the spoken complaints, which are commonplace enough in settled, comfortable relationships, is a deep, ancient and underlying bitterness. The ancient bitterness of women feeling invisible and ignored and the pain of thousands of generations right down the matrilineal line. From the hag’s point of view, she has a right to be outraged and vindictive for this is a collective image and a situation that she believes is the fault of all men.


Enter the Brute

The hag has a male counterpart, and whenever one surfaces within a relationship they seem to have the capacity to evoke the other. If women seek quality relationships from their men, then men seek above all acceptance and validation from their women. When this is met with constant undermining criticism something else takes over.

This male shadow principle we can call the brute, which, from the Latin brutus, means heavy, dull, stupid, describing anything without a rational soul and no faculty of reason. The brute is also hard, distant and impenetrable. He too is a figure from folklore and his wound is his inability to be touched emotionally and his incapacity to express anything at a feeling level.

The interactions that these dynamics create are unmistakable, poisonous and anti-life. You can see immediately when the dialogue between these two figures begins. The personal man and the personal woman seem to disappear when the hag and the brute enter the scene. The hag begins to rant, and the brute withdraws punishing and crippling everything feminine in his mate so that all that is feminine inevitably disappears. The more he hardens and distances himself the more she withdraws, rages or seethes. Both of the protagonists here are reasonable people, parents, children, siblings, neighbours, yet become something other, as if possessed, when activated in close relationships.

When in full play they feed off each other’s personal grievances and can potentially destroy any possibility of positive, enabling relationship. His cool distancing cruelty being as potent as the constancy of her endless critical negativity. The one evokes the other, the hag appearing unnoticed from her shadowed boundaries and the brute wielding his inarticulate emotional clubs, brutish, primitive with stony distance. Each deliberately cutting down the other, as self-contemptuous as the other.

Unfortunately, both of these figures have a way of inserting themselves into personal relationships with extraordinary regularity. This is the thing each fears in the other and it is the thing each would prefer not to recognise about themselves. The hag brings forth all of the themes of the castrator and devourer and like her ancient kin can suck the very life force from a man. She is a sort of shadow of the feminine principle, emerging when the capacity to love has been eclipsed by disappointment, and tenderness has withdrawn behind self-protection. She has learned that dependence invites pain, so values control over surrender and certainty over openness. She is not evil, but rather a version of a woman who has survived by hardening her heart. She possesses extraordinary gifts, knows how to endure the harshest winter, can cut through social untruths with remarkable clarity, has learned that every life asks something of us, and that there are losses we cannot bargain away. Without her, we remain naive.

The brute is the shadow of the masculine, belonging to the ancient instinct for survival, where strength means domination, emotion is a liability, and control the only protection against chaos. He fears vulnerability because it threatens his assumed identity, mistrusting intimacy he retreats into certainty, possession, or emotional distance. Not cruel by nature, but rather a version of a man who has survived by armouring his heart he too carries gifts. He remembers courage before there were words for it, knows how to stand his ground when the wolves gather and carries loyalty in his bones and an instinct to protect what he loves, even when he struggles to express that love.

Yet when triggered uncontrollably choosing distance and unassailability he manages to render his mate inconsequential beyond all measure. He might label her irrational and overemotional, she him, cold, hard, brutish, unfeeling and incapable of meeting her needs when, in the midst of this mutual punishing and crippling, both are right.

Yet somewhere beneath the hag’s hideousness still lives the once young woman who believed in love. And somewhere beneath the brute’s thick skin still beats the heart of the young man who longed to be understood and accepted. Their love, at these times, becomes less a meeting of souls than two separate survival strategies.

The curious thing is that these two seem to recognize each other immediately and so the dialogue begins… The hag begins to vent at the brute that he is not enough and cannot be so.

The brute looks back coldly and unemotionally, and mutters, “Exactly as I expected. Nothing I do will ever be enough,” before retreating back into stone. Proof to the hag that men cannot be relied upon or trusted, while the brute experiences the hag as proof that women are impossible to satisfy. Each becoming evidence for the other’s deepest fear.

The great tragedy here is that each partner mistakes the wound of the other for the person themselves. The hag no longer sees the frightened man beneath the armour while the brute no longer sees the wounded woman beneath the severity. Each responds to the other’s defences, reinforcing them until both become prisoners of an unconscious covenant severed from consciousness and compassion.

The master work here is not to banish either figure, which given their unconscious nature is no easy path, but to recognize them, even if but fleetingly, pause and step back so that once identified there is the space and possibility for what was once defended to become expressed through the heart. To meet with both these inner partners, undertake some active imagination, or journaling, dialogue with them in whatever is your way, offering sovereignty to one, who could perhaps never value her ‘self’ and gifting understanding and acceptance to the other, who in turn could never accept his ‘self’. This may take practice and time, for initially you may only become aware of them later, but you can still recall the dialogue, reflect on what was happening, replay it differently, so that these ancient enemies within the psyche may discover that they are not opponents after all. The hag recovers her sovereignty, her capacity for freedom of choice and agency and above all, her sense of value and becomes once again the beauteous, serene Lady Ragnell. While the brute’s survival instinct can evolve into a deep appreciation that gives true value to his mate, he might become once more a loving partner.

Together the brute and the hag make an interesting pair, since both figures mark the outer edge of what culture calls fully human, that is, opposite edges of the same boundary. The hag standing at the threshold of terror, annihilation and loss, and the brute at the threshold of instinctive, animal survival. Both are shadow figures who lurk each within the other and both are threshold dwellers, thresholds being those places where transformation happens.


The astrology

What has all this got to do with astrology? Start with Pluto, which seems to reflect some of the uncontrolled eruptive qualities of the Hag and also Uranus, as the cold, unavailable, unfeeling brute. An emphasis therefore in Scorpio or Aquarius, their ruling signs, can also constellate these figures more strongly although they can exist without such gender markers, male and female.

Also, look out for an absence of planets in air/water, or a singleton, especially if that singleton is either Pluto or Uranus. Having either of these in the 4th, 5th, 7th or 10th Houses should also be a red flag. Some aspects also may be problematical, especially the squares and oppositions of Uranus/Pluto, Venus/Pluto, Sun/Uranus, Moon/Uranus. These will really have the hag rushing in from the hedge groves while the brute silently paces up and down.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top